I will conceded they were also good in the Super Bowl loss, great for one half but somewhat iffy in the second half. But that game was on McNabb for the most part, not entirely but if there was one season ender I'd blame on him it would probably be that one even though even in that game he sure as hell had his moments, the three TD passes were lovely but the turnovers were killer. Especially the one to Bruschi. I've said many times that one bad pass probably defined McNabb's career and possibly the whole Andy Reid era. He doesn't throw the Bruschi pick, the Eagles win that game, McNabb would probably be headed for the hall of fame and the Eagles have a Super Bowl title.
Its sad one pass can define your career, but true.
He had another chance in 2008, but I don't care what anyone says the defense blew that one.