37 replies to this topic

[dmor]

http://www.pro-footb...hes/ReidAn0.htm

Please everyone, take a look at this coaching resume.

Sorry all the Reid haters, but the coach you see before you today isn't the guy that came here 14 years ago.  That guy just brought a string of good years to this city the likes of which it never saw in pro football.  His coaching staff and front office have been poached pretty good through the years.  And 14 years of running an organization and dysfunctional family can take its toll on anyone.

He gave us a lot more good than bad.  He's not giving up even though we're in free fall.  I'm going to miss those good Reid years and I really respect what the guy has done.

[New Zealand Eagle]

Terrible layout hard on my eyes/ terrible lay out makes it too hard to read for a lazy person.

[L.E.]

Overrated.

[EagleVA]

L.E., on 06 December 2012 - 07:25 PM, said:

Overrated.

Bigtime.

[Gimpy]

dmor, on 06 December 2012 - 06:45 PM, said:

http://www.pro-footb...hes/ReidAn0.htm

Please everyone, take a look at this coaching resume.

Sorry all the Reid haters, but the coach you see before you today isn't the guy that came here 14 years ago.  That guy just brought a string of good years to this city the likes of which it never saw in pro football.  His coaching staff and front office have been poached pretty good through the years.  And 14 years of running an organization and dysfunctional family can take its toll on anyone.

He gave us a lot more good than bad.  He's not giving up even though we're in free fall.  I'm going to miss those good Reid years and I really respect what the guy has done.

Sorry to the Reid haters? You're making the point for firing Reid.

[dmor]

Gimpy, on 06 December 2012 - 08:19 PM, said:

Sorry to the Reid haters? You're making the point for firing Reid.

If I've done so, it's not the intent.

[Utebird]

I too can appreciate Reid for what he did while here, 5 nfc championship games is no small feat, ive been a reid supporter for a long time but i think its best for him and the franchise if he moved on, seems stale.

[WestPaEaglesNest]

Took advantage of a weak NFC (particulary NFC East).  Once the NFC caught up with him, he has been outcoached more often than not.  The last 8 years, he is barely over .500.  Caution me about going back to the Rich Kotite/Ray Rhodes years?  What do you call 3-9?

[FanSinceWayBack]

I thought this was a "what have you done for me lately" league? Im not taking away Reids "PAST" success. What has he done for us lately?

[McNabbIsGone]

Why???

[kb420]

We can't live in the past.  Time only moves in one direction. We have to plan for the future.  The time for change is now!

FIRE ANDY REID NOW! ¡NO MÁS!

[McNabbIsGone]

WestPaEaglesNest, on 06 December 2012 - 08:40 PM, said:

Took advantage of a weak NFC (particulary NFC East).  Once the NFC caught up with him, he has been outcoached more often than not.  The last 8 years, he is barely over .500.  Caution me about going back to the Rich Kotite/Ray Rhodes years?  What do you call 3-9?

  In all fairness to Ray Rhodes: the Eags will have to lose-out to equal his 3 - 13. But yeah, we're clearly headed in that direction. Said another way, if the Eags go 4 - 12 or 5 - 11 it's not much better than Rhodes record. If the D can suddenly awake and play like they were billed they might have a shot at 7 - 9. WHOO-HOO.

[WestPaEaglesNest]

7-9 is worse case scenario.  3-13 is best.

[djbigf]

14 years with the same team and no championships is the only record that matters.  he got to cycle thru his "5-year superbowl plan" nearly 3 times and came up empty.  BFD

[CountBlah]

djbigf, on 06 December 2012 - 09:12 PM, said:

14 years with the same team and no championships is the only record that matters.  he got to cycle thru his "5-year superbowl plan" nearly 3 times and came up empty.  BFD

you know it's a universal truth if djkldjsf and I are in total agreement on something.  Reid's gotta go!!!!

[Caribbean Soul]

His record for the last 4 years is worse than Kotite's 4 years here and he's getting close to Rhodes.  Sorry but he's had his chance and he's failed and he has nothing and no one to blame except his own stubborness and arrogance.  He lost it in 05 and has gone down hill ever since with a 1 year exception.  He should have been fired long ago.

[PoconoDon]

Bye Bye Andy......Thanks for trying...just a shame you weren't good enough to get it done.

[PhillyEagleDude2]

You made the point to move on from the man.

[Nitro276]

The magic is gone, and the sand is just about out of the hour glass.  Not much time left to, you know, do a better job, take full responsibility, put the players in position to make plays....

[Runtherock]

Andy Reid is a bad human being and a played out coach, the sooner he's gone the better.

[skipsharp]

One look tells me he has coached for a long time. Too long.

[Innocence096]

Man that stretch from 200-2005 was fun. Since then though it hasn't been the same. I appreciate what he did here but the truth is it is time for him to go

[djbigf]

you can also look at andy reid's record here:

http://www.pro-footb.../F/FishJe20.htm

or here:

http://www.pro-footb.../S/SchoMa01.htm

[furiousxgeorge]

It's kind of sad that our "best coach ever" is overshadowed by our closest rival winning two Super Bowls (so far) during a shorter coaching tenure while we have nothing.

[SNOORDA]

There's a long list of some really good players w/o rings thanks to AR. Its really a shame.

[NOTW]

Reid's career has had 3 different stages.  He's been living off the success of the first phase the rest of his career.  The division titles, 4 of his 5 NFCCG appearances and winning regular season games against a weak NFC (but not having a good record against playoff teams) gave him padded stats in stage 1 but since then his records were bad.

In the 4 seasons after the Superbowl, his records were actually worse than Kotite's records that got him fired.

In the last 4 seasons, he currently has the exact same record as Kotite's 4 years.

So the last 8 seasons have been mediocre or worse.  The Andy Reid that everyone defends is in the past.  The Andy Reid we have now is ineffective and no longer has the accolades in the last 8 seasons.

It was time to go a long time ago.  I do appreciate what he did up to 2004. He had his run and didn't win the Superbowl but gave us some competitive winning football.  That's been on the decline though, and now the team is an embarrassment.

[McNabbIsGone]

WestPaEaglesNest, on 06 December 2012 - 09:00 PM, said:

7-9 is worse case scenario.  3-13 is best.

Agree. I'm all over that. As long as we're out of it we may as well  SUCK  as bad as we can be for a better draft pick. Think we'll draft an OL or a S first? I'd say OL but we need both.

[McNabbIsGone]

NOTW, on 07 December 2012 - 10:56 AM, said:

Reid's career has had 3 different stages.  He's been living off the success of the first phase the rest of his career.  The division titles, 4 of his 5 NFCCG appearances and winning regular season games against a weak NFC (but not having a good record against playoff teams) gave him padded stats in stage 1 but since then his records were bad.

In the 4 seasons after the Superbowl, his records were actually worse than Kotite's records that got him fired.

In the last 4 seasons, he currently has the exact same record as Kotite's 4 years.

So the last 8 seasons have been mediocre or worse.  The Andy Reid that everyone defends is in the past.  The Andy Reid we have now is ineffective and no longer has the accolades in the last 8 seasons.

It was time to go a long time ago.  I do appreciate what he did up to 2004. He had his run and didn't win the Superbowl but gave us some competitive winning football.  That's been on the decline though, and now the team is an embarrassment.

And now we get to play on & potentially be embarrassed on National TV again against the Bungles. Oh joy.

[BDAWK_4EVER]

Andy Kotite

[The Eagles win!]

L.E., on 06 December 2012 - 07:25 PM, said:

Overrated.

We'll see when he gets a new job.

The guy took the Eagles to the playoffs with multiple QBs.  He won a lot of games.  My guess is that he'll win a lot of games for the next team he coaches.