121 replies to this topic

[Cal_Eagles_Fan]

I know, everyone seems to be thinking he is done,  but I honestly think we will be seeing him again next year. I mean think about it, who out there is going to be a better coach? I think he has to change the personel around him,  but my gut says he will be here next year. Who is going to be available with better stats then Reid?  


Won  Lost  Ties  Win %  Finish  Won  Lost  Win %  Result
PHI  1999  5  11  0  .313  4th in NFC East  -  -  -  -
PHI  2000  11  5  0  .688  2nd in NFC East  1  1  .500  Lost to New York Giants in NFC Divisional Game.
PHI  2001  11  5  0  .688  1st in NFC East  2  1  .667  Lost to St. Louis Rams in NFC Championship Game.
PHI  2002  12  4  0  .750  1st in NFC East  1  1  .500  Lost to Tampa Bay Buccaneers in NFC Championship Game.
PHI  2003  12  4  0  .750  1st in NFC East  1  1  .500  Lost to Carolina Panthers in NFC Championship Game.
PHI  2004  13  3  0  .813  1st in NFC East  2  1  .667  Lost to New England Patriots in Super Bowl XXXIX.
PHI  2005  6  10  0  .375  4th in NFC East  -  -  -  -
PHI  2006  10  6  0  .625  1st in NFC East  1  1  .500  Lost to New Orleans Saints in NFC Divisional Game.
PHI  2007  8  8  0  .500  4th in NFC East  -  -  -  -
PHI  2008  9  6  1  .594  2nd in NFC East  2  1  .667  Lost to Arizona Cardinals in NFC Championship Game.
PHI  2009  11  5  0  .687  2nd in NFC East  0  1  .000  Lost to Dallas Cowboys in NFC Wild Card Game.
PHI  2010  10  6  0  .625  1st in NFC East  0  1  .000  Lost to Green Bay Packers in NFC Wild Card Game.
PHI  2011  8  8  0  .500  2nd in NFC East  -  -  -  -
PHI  2012  3  9  0  .250   -  -  -  -
PHI Total  129  90  1  .586   10  9  .526
Total  129  90  1  .586   10  9  .526

[iluvdaeagles]

i get that feeling as well

[stang8118]

I hope he stays. He needs to surround himself with better coaches though.

[GT500]

Gosh, I hope yall are wrong

[jonnyeagles12]

I wanted him out and still do to an extent. However,  I think with better coaches he may be better than what we can bring in. Foles and him obviously get on well too as he's the guy who drafted him.

[iluvdaeagles]

stang8118, on 09 December 2012 - 06:21 PM, said:

I hope he stays. He needs to surround himself with better coaches though.

this

[Hoagie]

Begin flame war in 3, 2, 1...

[BillTheButcher]

Always have said i like andy alot and wouldnt be mad at all to see him play out his contract.

[Cal_Eagles_Fan]

iluvdaeagles, on 09 December 2012 - 06:22 PM, said:

this

Agreed

[mike030270]

They won 1 game after an 8 game losing streak. He lost his bye record. He's made horrible hiring/firing decisions lately. he had 4 RBs this season and didn't use them all. He kept Vick in until Vick got a concussion. 1 game doesn't solidify his return

[wrestlevessel]

I want him out. He sucks and is a moron.

[stang8118]

wrestlevessel, on 09 December 2012 - 06:25 PM, said:

I want him out. He sucks and is a moron.

Yup. Morons have a 58% winning percentage over a 14 year career. Especially when he has his thumb print on every part of this team.

[Cal_Eagles_Fan]

mike030270, on 09 December 2012 - 06:24 PM, said:

They won 1 game after an 8 game losing streak. He lost his bye record. He's made horrible hiring/firing decisions lately. he had 4 RBs this season and didn't use them all. He kept Vick in until Vick got a concussion. 1 game doesn't solidify his return

That was not my point. I am looking for someone to tell me what coach is going to come in that Laurie can clearly say, OK this guy will come in and do a better job. There are still a ton of things about this season that you can say caused Andy to have a bad year. O-line decimated, 3 offensive starters out etc. Listen,  I am not saying he has had a good year,  i am simply trying to think of it from an owners perspective.

[CountBlah]

I reall hope not.  At least give me hope that we could win a Super Bowl next year.  With Reid, there is no hope of that happening.

[wrestlevessel]

Do a better job is a good coach? You got to be kidding me? The way he runs this team is a joke. Everyone knows how to stop us. He is a disgrace. Kid dying shouldn't be an excuse. He had a losing year!

[Cal_Eagles_Fan]

wrestlevessel, on 09 December 2012 - 06:34 PM, said:

Do a better job is a good coach? You got to be kidding me? The way he runs this team is a joke. Everyone knows how to stop us. He is a disgrace. Kid dying shouldn't be an excuse. He had a losing year!

Who is going to be better?

[stang8118]

wrestlevessel, on 09 December 2012 - 06:34 PM, said:

Do a better job is a good coach? You got to be kidding me? The way he runs this team is a joke. Everyone knows how to stop us. He is a disgrace. Kid dying shouldn't be an excuse. He had a losing year!

There is no guarantee that the next coach will be better, and there is no guarantee that Reid will never win a Super Bowl.

Though there is always a chance that we find a more successful coach that wins us a Super Bowl. To sit here and say with certainty that firing Reid is the best option just proves your ignorance.

[mikelewisdaman]

The CEO of the team said Andy needs to do better than 8-8 and the wins at the end of the 2011 season were fool's gold.  The team is currently 4-9 and 60% of the seats are empty at home games.  Andy is gone, stop being contrarians, anyone with two brain cells to rub together can see this.  Andy didn't hire Tommy Brasher to be the dline coach because he thought he'd be here longer than a few games.  Mudd has already announced his retirement. The party is over, turn out the lights.

[Cal_Eagles_Fan]

We all know Reid is the best option to develop Foles anyways, so why fire him before that happens?

[mikelewisdaman]

Cal_Eagles_Fan, on 09 December 2012 - 06:44 PM, said:

We all know Reid is the best option to develop Foles anyways, so why fire him before that happens?

Because the last QB Reid developed was Donovan McNabb, a decade ago.  There's no firm evidence saying Andy has the ability to develop a championship quarterback. None.  Stop.

[Sack that QB]

No he won't. We just won(barely) one Fing game after losing 8 in a row. He's gone.

[Jesus Zoidberg]

He's cooked.

[bwestbrook36]

There is no certainty either way but, come on. Then no coaches should ever be fired cause the next guy might be worse then the next. Ray Roades won a dam playoff game so i guess we should not of fired him cause Reid might of had us in the cellar and won no playoff games.

Not sure what my point is lol, i just know i want the team to go in a different direction

[BillTheButcher]

mikelewisdaman, on 09 December 2012 - 06:47 PM, said:

Because the last QB Reid developed was Donovan McNabb, a decade ago.  There's no firm evidence saying Andy has the ability to develop a championship quarterback. None.  Stop.

gotta win a championship to do that.

[Krukslonelyball]

laughing out loud

[Cal_Eagles_Fan]

mikelewisdaman, on 09 December 2012 - 06:47 PM, said:

Because the last QB Reid developed was Donovan McNabb, a decade ago.  There's no firm evidence saying Andy has the ability to develop a championship quarterback. None.  Stop.

Please. I bet you won't find many other experts in the league who don't think the guy is great at developing QB's.  That said, you still have not answered my question WHO is going to be available and a better choice?

[joegus]

The epitome of stupidity would be to retain Reid. The game tonight proved it again. Andy and Marty cannot help themselves. They completely abandoned the run in the second half and were ridiculous in the shotgun formation all night. Fortunately, Foles performed well and proved he can be the caliber player they need.

The staleness of Reid and the stupidity of Marty will not get fixed. They need to go.

[Sack that QB]

That's such a dumb way of looking at it. How is an unproven coach going to have better "stats" than Reid? They need the chance to coach first. What a stupid argument.

[Eagle_69]

if he stays, as long as its with a new coaching support staff OC, DC, i wont be too upset.
Id prefer him gone though and i still think he will be, unless Foles wins out, Lurie buys into him as the franchise and Foles then pushes hard for Ried to be around to mentor him

[kristiandroc2004]

I disagree with abandoning the run...

However, I STRONGLY disagree with running play action passes if you abandon the run. It makes NO sense whatsoever.