150 replies to this topic

[VaBeach_Eagle]

Peyton Manning? Nick Folezz!?1 Mark Sanchez? Someone else?

Who should get the nod?

I'm thinking Peyton.

ROY probably to Luck or Griffin.

[RedskinsFan01]

RG3, obviously.

[downundermike]

AP.....All Day

[NorCalEagle]

peyton's going to win it...

[Happyfoosball]

Peyton Manning and it's not even close.  Looking at where Denver was, now where they are.  Slam dunk.

[VaBeach_Eagle]

RedskinsFan01, on 13 December 2012 - 06:56 PM, said:

RG3, obviously.

I could see ROY coming down to him or Luck but not MVP. They'd have to win the Super Bowl to make that happen and even then, the MVP is named before the Super Bowl.

[EaglesFan5327]

Adrian Peterson or Peyton Manning

[CharGP02A]

J.J Watt.

[Gmen2005]

downundermike, on 13 December 2012 - 06:58 PM, said:

AP.....All Day

Agreed, but I doubt he wins because I don't see the Vikings making the playoffs.

[Bravens1]

Manning by light years..

[PhillyEagleDude2]

If the Vikings make the playoffs it has to AP All Day,  every day.  Broncos was a playoff team without Peyton last year and it would just be nice to see a BEAST RB win it.  Im not a big RB guy but AP is my favorite non Eagles player offensive player in this league without a doubt.  It is a pleasure to watch this man play football from that position.

[ckudrick]

Manning will win.

[nezzy]

Uhhh Tom Brady?

[Innocence096]

Happyfoosball, on 13 December 2012 - 07:05 PM, said:

Peyton Manning and it's not even close.  Looking at where Denver was, now where they are.  Slam dunk.

a division winner to a division winner?

I am going with Peterson. He is the reason the Vikings are even in playoff contention.

[Happyfoosball]

Innocence096, on 14 December 2012 - 02:40 AM, said:

a division winner to a division winner?

I am going with Peterson. He is the reason the Vikings are even in playoff contention.

yeah an 8-8 division winner with Tim Tebow that got wiped out in the playoffs vs. a 10-3 division winner with 3 games to play that could easily win the super bowl.  Yeah like I said Peyton Manning.  2. is Peterson.  If Ponder didn't suck Peterson would have a legit chance to win the award but as we all know team success is factored in.

[ggs5008]

Brady or Peterson should win it.

I mean Tebow won games with this Broncos defense. They have a very good team surrounding him.

Vikings without Peterson would have won maybe 2 or 3 games max. Brady is Brady.

Happyfoosball, on 14 December 2012 - 03:02 AM, said:

yeah an 8-8 division winner with Tim Tebow that got wiped out in the playoffs vs. a 10-3 division winner with 3 games to play that could easily win the super bowl.  Yeah like I said Peyton Manning.  2. is Peterson. If Ponder didn't suck Peterson would have a legit chance to win the award but as we all know team success is factored in.

Even more the reason he deserves it. Teams can load the box because no one fears Ponder. Manning has a great defense and surrounding offensive players.

[mike030270]

Peyton. It's not even close

[bumpy93]

VaBeach_Eagle, on 13 December 2012 - 06:55 PM, said:

Peyton Manning? Nick Folezz!?1 Mark Sanchez? Someone else?

Who should get the nod?

I'm thinking Peyton.

I wanna say Peyton Manning BUT because Tim Tebow helped the Broncos win the division last season shows that the Broncos werent that bad of a team in the 1st place IMO.

I think a MVP should be someone that if you took them off of that team they would be completley horrible that makes Peyton unavaiable to win that award. IMO the winner of the MVP award this year should be..............

ANDREW LUCK or RG3

Yes I said it

the Colts were 2-14 last year and now they are 9-4 with one of the weakest rosters in the NFL. RG3 is doing the same thing in DC. They are only 7-6 (redskins) but if RG3 wasnt the QB they would be bad like they have been the last 10 years IMO

[mike030270]

bumpy93, on 14 December 2012 - 11:35 AM, said:

I wanna say Peyton Manning BUT because Tim Tebow helped the Broncos win the division last season shows that the Broncos werent that bad of a team in the 1st place IMO.

I think a MVP should be someone that if you took them off of that team they would be completley horrible that makes Peyton unavaiable to win that award. IMO the winner of the MVP award this year should be..............

ANDREW LUCK or RG3

Yes I said it

the Colts were 2-14 last year and now they are 9-4 with one of the weakest rosters in the NFL. RG3 is doing the same thing in DC. They are only 7-6 (redskins) but if RG3 wasnt the QB they would be bad like they have been the last 10 years IMO

Did you forget why Peyton wasn't playing last season? Luck or RG3?? Those 2 shouldn't even be rookie of the year, that should go to Wilson. Both Luck and RG3 had easy schedules

[hukdonfoniks]

Adrian Peterson without a doubt.  he's getting zero help from anyone else on his offense and he's still pushing close to 2,000 yards.

[Pegger]

League MVP =  Peyton
Defensive = JJ Watt
Comeback = Peterson
Offensive = Brady

Offensive Rookie = RG3
Defensive Rookie = Kuechly
Coach of the year = M. Smith (Atlanta)

[Rodney_Zero]

Happyfoosball, on 13 December 2012 - 07:05 PM, said:

Peyton Manning and it's not even close.  Looking at where Indy was, now where they are.  Slam dunk.

You say that about Andrew Luck too

Pegger, on 14 December 2012 - 04:14 PM, said:

League MVP =  Peyton
Defensive = JJ Watt
Comeback = Peterson
Offensive = Brady

Offensive Rookie = RG3
Defensive Rookie = Kuechly
Coach of the year = M. Smith (Atlanta)

130 tackles, dude was not overhyped as many thought, his instincts are off the charts

[Happyfoosball]

Rodney_Zero, on 14 December 2012 - 04:26 PM, said:

You say that about Andrew Luck too


130 tackles, dude was not overhyped as many thought, his instincts are off the charts

No I was half awake when I made that post.  I meant to say Denver.  I stand by that, it's Peyton Manning.  Not even close.

[VaBeach_Eagle]

bumpy93, on 14 December 2012 - 11:35 AM, said:

I wanna say Peyton Manning BUT because Tim Tebow helped the Broncos win the division last season shows that the Broncos werent that bad of a team in the 1st place IMO.

They made the playoffs last year, but weren't a very good team. They made the playoffs because of their division and how badly it sucked.

Denver 8-8
San Diego 8-8
Oakland 8-8
Kansas City 7-9

This year, with 3 games left, the Broncos are already 2 games better than 2011. Last year, in 16 games Denver had -81 net points and 36 TDs. This year, after 13 games they have 118 points and 44 TDs. Negative 81 points to positive 114 points (so far)... that's a HUGE difference.

So there's a huge difference when you look at the 2011 Broncos and the 2012 Broncos. What's that difference? Peyton Manning and nothing else.

[Happyfoosball]

VaBeach_Eagle, on 14 December 2012 - 07:55 PM, said:

They made the playoffs last year, but weren't a very good team. They made the playoffs because of their division and how badly it sucked.

Denver 8-8
San Diego 8-8
Oakland 8-8
Kansas City 7-9

This year, with 3 games left, the Broncos are already 2 games better than 2011. Last year, in 16 games Denver had -81 net points and 36 TDs. This year, after 13 games they have 118 points and 44 TDs. Negative 81 points to positive 114 points (so far)... that's a HUGE difference.

So there's a huge difference when you look at the 2011 Broncos and the 2012 Broncos. What's that difference? Peyton Manning and nothing else.

Almost a difference in 200 points, and the award is for most valuable player, not the best.  It's Manning's award.  He's been the most valuable player in the NFL this year.

[NorCalEagle]

peyton's also going to get the comeback player award...while peterson's season has been incredible, & what he's doing is insane, he only missed one game last year...in the context of an nfl season, he really didn't go anywhere to come back from...

tho i could see ap & peyton sharing that award...

[E v 2.0]

To me it's Peyton every year by default. He or Brady.

I would never give it to a running back.

[Froggy]

I'm gonna rep...Brady actually is quietly having another fantastic season. His last 3 regular seasons have been biblical statistically speaking. He hasn't lost in December in 3 years, in fact, he has lost only 2 times in the least three Novembers and Decembers combined, and he has thrown no more than 3 interceptions in that stretch.

[bandwagon]

VaBeach_Eagle, on 14 December 2012 - 07:55 PM, said:

They made the playoffs last year, but weren't a very good team. They made the playoffs because of their division and how badly it sucked.

The AFC West is much worse this year than it was last. It's easily the worst division in football this year, the Chargers, Raiders and Chiefs are just plain awful. The Broncos made the playoffs last year and won a playoff game, they'll most likely do the same this year. You can throw out all the statistical improvements you want but the bottom line is the Broncos, in my opinion, will go just as far as they did last year. They are not a Super Bowl caliber team. So besides statistical improvements, if the Broncos fail to win a single playoff game or win 1 as they did last year the arguement can be made that they really didn't improve at all. They don't have any wins against impressive teams and got beat by Atlanta, Houston and New England, the only division leading teams they've played.

To sum it up I'm not sold on the Broncos or Peyton Manning, in my opinion Tom Brady and Adrian Peterson are more deserving of the MVP award.

[bumpy93]

I think Manning will win the award. I just think that Denver wasnt a bad team before he signed there.

RG3 has something like 18TDs to 4 ints for a rookie. Thats amazing foe any QB let alone a rookie on a horrible team IMO