186 replies to this topic

[eagle45]

SirReal, on 30 December 2012 - 11:10 AM, said:

You can't seriously be comparing the raw numbers of Roseman's 2.5 drafts with the raw numbers of the 20 drafts that came before, ignoring 2011 completely, and disregarding the fact that losing teams don't get many Pro Bowl picks, just to show that Roseman is bad.

Take a statistics class.

Hell, read about statistics on Wikipedia. Even THAT will put you ahead of where you are now.

  I've literally forgetten more about stats in the last half hour than you will ever know.   r

[Eagle Jeff]

Most people who post here don't even know who Howie Roseman is.  They just know that Cataldi told them he's awful so they then come on here and regurgitate what he said.

Most people who post here don't even know who Howie Roseman is.  They just know that Cataldi told them he's awful so they then come on here and regurgitate what he said.

[SirReal]

eagle45, on 30 December 2012 - 01:15 PM, said:

  I've literally forgetten more about stats in the last half hour than you will ever know.   r

If you're going for a one-to-one comparison between a group collected over ten years with a group collected over two, then perhaps you should try to get that half hour back.

[DonCornelious]

Eagle Jeff, on 30 December 2012 - 01:21 PM, said:

Most people who post here don't even know who Howie Roseman is.  They just know that Cataldi told them he's awful so they then come on here and regurgitate what he said.

Most people who post here don't even know who Howie Roseman is.  They just know that Cataldi told them he's awful so they then come on here and regurgitate what he said.

I don't know who Cataldi is, but I have seen enough of Howie Roseman to know I don't want him heading up my personnel or picking my coach.


I don't know who Cataldi is, but I have seen enough of Howie Roseman to know I don't want him heading up my personnel or picking my coach.


I don't know who Cataldi is, but I have seen enough of Howie Roseman to know I don't want him heading up my personnel or picking my coach.

[#99]

He was here when we picked Watkins, so he can't be very good, smart or knowledgable in the evaluation process.  Is "discovering" Colt his best claim to fame?  Why should I be impressed with Howie?

[eagle45]

SirReal, on 30 December 2012 - 03:09 PM, said:

If you're going for a one-to-one comparison between a group collected over ten years with a group collected over two, then perhaps you should try to get that half hour back.

If you're going to lecture people on stats, at least try to have your own tracks covered.  A one to one comparison between a group compiled over 10 years versus a group compiled over 2 would be counting all probowlers the eagles drafted in 10 years prior to Roseman...against all probowlers Roseman acquired in 2.

Roseman inherited a roster with 9 probowlers.  And after 3 offseasons under his guidance, he has a roster with 0.  It's not that complicated.

Go back to class.

[SirReal]

Gotcha. You're blaming Roseman for injuries, dropped passes, fumbles, interceptions, blown playcalling, poor clock management, and a dozen or more past Pro Bowlers playing like crap.

Dude, those same Pro Bowlers are still on the team, or most, and we brought in MORE Pro Bowlers. Roseman cannot possibly be blamed for Demigod Ashomoguha playing like a Pop Warner player, DRC playing out of position, Young being crap, Brown being worse crap, and so on.