43 replies to this topic

[cmart102]

Shocker54, on 26 January 2013 - 05:26 PM, said:

If anything Wisconsin o lineman besides joe Thomas are busts

I watched konz and Carimi get rocked all season

Konz is solid. Zeitler is a beast. Carimi sucks tho

[SP]

Eagle Gator 12, on 25 January 2013 - 11:19 AM, said:

I wanted to add Adrian Clayborn who has been eh for a 1st rounder too. But yeah I'm an SEC fan and we have had our fair share of DL busts but man it seems like these Big 10 DL get sooooo much hype then just stall in the league.

Like Derrick Harvey, right?  Big Ten linemen don't bust any more than the SEC linemen, my friend.

Jermaine Cunningham? Serviceable.
Carlos Dunlap?  Similar to Jason Babin.
Jarvis Moss? LOL
Ray McDonald?  Serviceable.
Marcus Thomas? LOL
Joe Cohen? LOL
Alex Brown? LOL
Reggie McGrew? LOL

Should I go through the other SEC schools, or do you want me to keep pointing out Gator busts?

[Eagle Gator 12]

SP, on 27 January 2013 - 11:44 PM, said:

Like Derrick Harvey, right?  Big Ten linemen don't bust any more than the SEC linemen, my friend.

Jermaine Cunningham? Serviceable.
Carlos Dunlap?  Similar to Jason Babin.
Jarvis Moss? LOL
Ray McDonald?  Serviceable.
Marcus Thomas? LOL
Joe Cohen? LOL
Alex Brown? LOL
Reggie McGrew? LOL

Should I go through the other SEC schools, or do you want me to keep pointing out Gator busts?

Lol I don't even know why i bother with. Can't even see my point when I admitted SEC has had busts, they just skip over that fact and tell me the SEC has had busts like I didn't just say that. Thanks apparently I haven't said the SEC has had busts 3-4 times now, thanks for pointing this out to me. Apparently to anyone reading this post the SEC has had busts!!! I had no clue and didn't say it any in this thread!!! Lol

Please tell me your school buddy and let me research your busts like you just did. Haha cuz i can guarantee there's plenty

Also where do you get joe Cohen, Alex brown and Marcus Thomas being busts? 4th round picks? That's not a bust buddy lol

So you get Jarvis Moss, Mcgrew and McDonald wasn't a bust he's a very good player and starts some, BUT he wasn't 1st round pick material. So 2 and half busts this decade. OH NOZ

I'm sure you'll try to look up more but I honestly don't care. Lol

[SP]

Wait a minute, didn't you say in another thread that Maclin is a bust because he's not playing at a first round level?  Then by that logic McDonald is a bust too. Can't have it both ways.

You did say that the SEC has busts, but you ALSO said the Big Ten has more. And there's no data that shows a correlation.  Also, when there's only 9 defensive linemen picked in the first two rounds over the decade, then it's a fair assessment.  Harvey and Moss were HUGE busts.  McGrew too.  That's not including Gerard Warren, who most Browns fans are split on.

I'm a Michigan man, who went to Ohio State for school. So pick your poison.

[Eagle Gator 12]

SP, on 28 January 2013 - 01:57 PM, said:

Wait a minute, didn't you say in another thread that Maclin is a bust because he's not playing at a first round level?  Then by that logic McDonald is a bust too. Can't have it both ways.

You did say that the SEC has busts, but you ALSO said the Big Ten has more. And there's no data that shows a correlation.  Also, when there's only 9 defensive linemen picked in the first two rounds over the decade, then it's a fair assessment.  Harvey and Moss were HUGE busts.  McGrew too.  That's not including Gerard Warren, who most Browns fans are split on.

I'm a Michigan man, who went to Ohio State for school. So pick your poison.

Absolutely never said that about Maclin. Not a shot, I'm the same guy who defends Graham. I am a Maclin supporter and criticize those who want him gone. Don't have the slightest clue where you pulled that from. This conversation shouldn't even be continued from you putting words in my mouth. I can personally gaurantee you search all my post and will never find those words, now I agree maclin has under performed and is injury prone, but I have never called him a bust.. I haven't called a single player on this team a bust but I am approaching it with Danny Watkins. Hell I still want Coleman and Allen on this team, just not as starters.

Wrong person.

[SP]

Eagle Gator 12, on 28 January 2013 - 02:15 PM, said:

Absolutely never said that about Maclin. Not a shot, I'm the same guy who defends Graham. I am a Maclin supporter and criticize those who want him gone. Don't have the slightest clue where you pulled that from. This conversation shouldn't even be continued from you putting words in my mouth. I can personally gaurantee you search all my post and will never find those words, now I agree maclin has under performed and is injury prone, but I have never called him a bust.. I haven't called a single player on this team a bust but I am approaching it with Danny Watkins. Hell I still want Coleman and Allen on this team, just not as starters.

Wrong person.

You're right, sorry.  I was talking with Holleman, who is also a Gators fan.  My apologies.  But go on...

[Shocker54]

Everyone's knows Floridas pros usually suck

[Eagle Gator 12]

Shocker54, on 28 January 2013 - 06:18 PM, said:

Everyone's knows Floridas pros usually suck

Yeah I guess
Lito Shepherd
Brandon spikes
Percy Harvin
Carlos Dunlap
Jabari Gaffney
Channing Crowder
Riley Cooper
Andra Davis
Ernest Graham
Joe Haden
Aaron Hernandez
Jeremy Mincey
David Nelson
Reggie Nelson
Max Starks
Fred Taylor
Emmitt Smith
Gerald warren
Major wright
Ahmad Black
Lomas Brown
Wilber Marshall
Mike Peterson
Fred Weary
Janoris Jenkins
BOTH pounceys
Ike Hilliard
Jevon kearse
Kevin carter
Jack Youngblood
Errict Rhett

We're all terrible. I'm done with this thread

[ams533]

Tamba Hali would be another successful recent DL out of the Big 10. Like someone else said, DL is one of the most difficult positions to project towards the NFL. You're going to find a bunch of busts there, regardless of conference affiliation.

[Innocence096]

Eagle Gator 12, on 25 January 2013 - 11:19 AM, said:

I wanted to add Adrian Clayborn who has been eh for a 1st rounder too. But yeah I'm an SEC fan and we have had our fair share of DL busts but man it seems like these Big 10 DL get sooooo much hype then just stall in the league.

He had nearly 50 tackles and 7.5 sacks as a rookie!!! This past year he blew out his knee early on. What are you talking about? it's clear you don't have a clue

[Rodney_Zero]

SP, on 27 January 2013 - 11:44 PM, said:

.

Should I go through the other SEC schools, or do you want me to keep pointing out Gator busts?

Jack Youngblood
Kevin Carter
Jevon Kearse
Brad Culepepper

[SP]

Eagle Gator 12, on 28 January 2013 - 08:00 PM, said:

Yeah I guess
Carlos Dunlap
Jeremy Mincey
Gerald warren
Jevon kearse
Kevin carter
Jack Youngblood

We're all terrible. I'm done with this thread

So let's get back to defensive linemen, thanks. Only one man there had an All-Pro season. Wooooooooo.

[jrsu37]

Alex Brown was not a bust at all.

[Rodney_Zero]

SP, on 30 January 2013 - 08:57 PM, said:

So let's get back to defensive linemen, thanks. Only one man there had an All-Pro season. Wooooooooo.

Kearse and Carter where All Pros IIRC, Youngblood is in the HOF