13 replies to this topic

[KillerBirds11]

Say OT Joeckel is gone, DE Moore is gone... obviously one more player will be gone but this is hypothetical. These are the 3 biggest names to us at #4, so if we had our choice on the 3, who would it be?

I would take Star personally, bc he is just a dominant DT and in a 3-4 a NT is probably the most important.

[vipakabp916]

trade down...

[rstarter]

I'd take Star too, but I'm very skeptical as to whether Star can be an effective NT in the league if not right away. Some guys on here suggest using him as a 3-4 end which I agree with, I mean he has the quickness and size but I've not seen (from highlights) too many plays where he occupies two blockers effectively. In any case, draft him and hope to get Daniel McCullers next year.

[EaglesCB37]

If we switch to a 3-4 and he's available, I'm fine taking Lotulelei (although I think he'll go to the Raiders at #3). If we stay in a 4-3, I'd rather trade down depending on which team wants to trade down, i.e. if the Cards, Bills, or Jets want Geno Smith we could swap picks with them and grab Milliner.

[WaitingForSomeday]

I'm running to the podium...

[Robbieb77]

Star or Milliner would be fine. Voted Milliner

[wild_wild_west]

I wouldnt mind Star or Milliner, but that depends on if you maintain the 4-3 or not.  Personally, I think in either case i would prefer to trade back and to later in the top 10 and draft Warmack, if you can find a willing partner.  I think if you plan to move to a 3-4 you are giving up on competing next year cause you wont have any personnel to play it, so trading back to get another pick to get a true NT later would be the best option, but if your stuck at 4 Milliner is a better option.  I dont think Star gives you top 5 value at NT.  If you stay with the 4-3 Star projects as a stud DT and could be your pick.

[chess4]

Miliner.....Sylvester Williams is as good as SStar for half the money.  Only reason Sly aint being drafted higher is because he had some off the field stuff

[FanSinceWayBack]

trade down... whats 4-5 spots when you need as much help as we do... picking up an extra second would be alot more beneficial IMO

[Coleman42]

If we trade down it should be for Chance!

[BirdGang45]

Trade back and get Rhodes

[Asiragusa]

BirdGang45, on 01 February 2013 - 10:51 PM, said:

Trade back and get Rhodes

My pick would be to trade down and take either Dion Jordan or Xavier Rhodes

[Sean Jerz]

It depends on what's done in free agency. We get a OT and S then I'd say get Jarvis Jones. 3-4 or 4-3, the kid would come in and start from day one. Jones, Moore or Star would be my choice at #4 in that order..

[BirdGang45]

Asiragusa, on 02 February 2013 - 01:49 PM, said:

My pick would be to trade down and take either Dion Jordan or Xavier Rhodes

Either one of those i would be fine with. Prefer Rhodes, but Dion would still be a good pick