Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

gaitherfan

Top 5 Lists: Offense

Recommended Posts

RB

1. Westbrook

2. Booker

3. Tyson Thompson

4. Mike Sellers

5. Reuben Droughns

WR

1. Curtis

2. Brown

3. Miles Austin

4. Reche Caldwell

5. Domenik Hixon

TE

1. L.J.

2. Celek

3. Tony Curtis

4. Michael Matthews

5. Todd Yoder

QB

1. McNabb

2. Brad Johnson

3. Antwaan Randle El

4. Anthony Wright

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
RB

1. Westbrook

2. Barber

3. Portis

4. Jacobs

5. Felix Jones ***** he's never played! Betts is 5*****

WR

1. Owens

2. Burress

3. Moss

4. Brown

5. Crayton

*****Brown isn't even the best WR on the Eagles.. Curtis is right now. Santana Moss has disappeared after his 1 or 2 exploding seasons. He also can't beat a double team for his life. Steve Smith could explode onto this list this year, but it's a little remature now*****

TE

1. Witten

2. Cooley

3. Shockey

4. Smith

5. Boss

QB

1. Romo

2. McNabb

3. Manning

4. Campbell

*****Romo and McNabb are pretty interchangable right now. A healthy McNabb would get a slight nod, but he hasn't been healthy, so he is what he is and I don't necessarily disagree with this rating. Pretty good rankings overall.*****

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Moss is a game breaker when healthy. I think Burress is crazy overrated.
Last year Burress finally became what many teams around the league feared he could be when properly motivated. When watching that NFLN fluff piece of the Eagles the other day they showed that TD catch he made against us in the second game. Straight up sick TD grab.

When I look at season stats I weigh TD receptions heavily. TD's are where the W's come from and he pulled in 12 last year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
RB

1. Westbrook

2. Booker

3. Tyson Thompson

4. Mike Sellers

5. Reuben Droughns

WR

1. Curtis

2. Brown

3. Miles Austin

4. Reche Caldwell

5. Domenik Hixon

TE

1. L.J.

2. Celek

3. Tony Curtis

4. Michael Matthews

5. Todd Yoder

QB

1. McNabb

2. Brad Johnson

3. Antwaan Randle El

4. Anthony Wright

As funny as this list is, it's much better than the original post. :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

RB

1)westbrook

2)barber

3)jacobs

4)portis

5)buckhalter(yes i said it. he is very underappreciated)

WR

1)owens

2)burress

3)moss

4) curtis

5)smith(giants)

TE

1)witten

2)cooley

3)smith

4)kevin boss

5)shockey

QB

1)eli

2)mcnabb

3)romo

4)collins

5)campbell

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Celek is way better then Kevin Boss. I dont understand why people thought he would replace shockey. Boss had 9 catches in 13 games in the regular season, and 5 catches in the postseason in 4 games.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
RB

1)westbrook

2)barber

3)jacobs

4)portis

5)buckhalter(yes i said it. he is very underappreciated)

WR

1)owens

2)burress

3)moss

4) curtis

5)smith(giants)

TE

1)witten

2)cooley

3)smith

4)kevin boss

5)shockey

QB

1)eli

2)mcnabb

3)romo

4)collins

5)campbell

Are you high?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
RB

1. Westbrook

2. Barber

3. Portis

4. Jacobs

5. Felix Jones

WR

1. Owens

2. Burress

3. Moss

4. Brown

5. Crayton

TE

1. Witten

2. Cooley

3. Shockey

4. Smith

5. Boss

QB

1. Romo

2. McNabb

3. Manning

4. Campbell

Felix Jones hasnt done a damn thing in the nfl yet so you can wipe that off, crayton ant **** and curtis is way way better than him as well as brown, boss hasnt done **** but catch 5 passes so he shouldnt be on there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
RB

1. Westbrook

2. Barber

3. Portis

4. Jacobs

5. Felix Jones

WR

1. Owens

2. Burress

3. Moss

4. Brown

5. Crayton

TE

1. Witten

2. Cooley

3. Shockey

4. Smith

5. Boss

QB

1. Romo

2. McNabb

3. Manning

4. Campbell

Why didn't you just post this in the other thread?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A. Stop stealing my threads.

2. KC not in the top 5 WRs?

D. Inclusion of Felix Jones and Patrick Crayton?

WHAT THE EFF DUDE?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'd but Barber at #2

He's never been a true starter, whereas Portis has been consistently a top 10-15 back in the NFL for YEARS now. Portis is also one of the nastiest pass blocking backs I've ever seen.

ALSO, made a few edits.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
are you serious? You put Runyan and Thomas behind Diehl and Adams? Runyan should be number 1 but putting them at 4 and 5?

Insane. Runyan shouldn't even be on the list.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quarterbacks:

1. Donovan McNabb

2. Tony Romo

3. Eli Manning

4. Jason Campbell

5. Todd Collins

Running Backs:

1. Brian Westbrook

2. Clinton Portis

3. Marion Barber

4. Brandon Jacobs

5. Ladell Betts

Tight Ends:

1. Jason Witten

2. Jeremy Shockey

3. Chris Cooley

4. LJ Smith

5. Kevin Boss/Brent Celek (EDIT)

Wide Receivers:

1. Terrell Owens

2. Santana Moss

3. Plaxico Burress

4. Kevin Curtis

5. Amani Toomer/Reggie Brown

Tackles:

1. Chris Samuels/Jon Runyan (EDIT)

3. David Diehl

4. Tra Thomas (EDIT)

5. Flozell Adams (EDIT)

Guards/Centers:

1. Shawn Andrews

2. Leonard Davis

3. Chris Snee

4. Andre Gurode

5. Jamaal Jackson/Randy Thomas (EDIT)

EDITS MADE ON JULY 5TH AT 11:40 PM.

QBs

1. Tony Romo

2. Eli Manning

3. Donovan McNabb

4. Jason Campbell

RBs

1. Brian Westbrook

2. Marion Barber

3. Clinton Portis

4. Brandon Jacobs

WRs

1. Owens

2. Burress

3. Moss

4. Kevin Curtis

5. Reggie Brown

TEs

1. Witten

2. Chris Cooley

3. Jeremy Shockey

4. Kevin Boss

5. LJ Smith

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Portis is also one of the nastiest pass blocking backs I've ever seen.
It's funny watching him. He'll often completely lay himself out just to destroy someone in pass pro.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I agree with you. I know Brown isn't a top 25 WR in the NFL, but he is a top 5 WR in the division. And I do know Curtis had a better year last year, but if I had to start a team, I would take Brown over Curtis.

WHY?????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

While I don't think Curtis and Brown are top flight caliber WR...I would blame McNabb just as much for the lack of success Brown has had. Sorry...in 08, D Mac held onto the ball and continued to have accuracy problems.

Fact is T.O. is so good at getting open and separating, he makes QBs look good. Donovan doesn't have those guys that can do that...but how many WR in the league are as good as T.O.? What Donovan often fails to do is give his WR a chance to make a play.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
It's funny watching him. He'll often completely lay himself out just to destroy someone in pass pro.

I don't get how many people keep trying to say that Barber should be ahead of him. Portis has consistently been a top RB. The ONLY thing Barber has on him is youth...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I don't get how many people keep trying to say that Barber should be ahead of him. Portis has consistently been a top RB. The ONLY thing Barber has on him is youth...

Okay right now which RB would you rather have on your team: Barber or Portis?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Okay right now which RB would you rather have on your team: Barber or Portis?

Portis, HANDS DOWN!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
TEs

1. Witten

2. Chris Cooley

3. Jeremy Shockey

4. Kevin Boss

5. LJ Smith

Boss over Smith is laughable.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites