Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

eagles_crazy

Rank the NFC East quarterbacks now!

Recommended Posts

I'll rank them in February, 2011.

Good answer.

Kolb could be shockingly better than many think or he could be a let-down. We have no way of knowing yet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1st - Wash with Mcnabb (I am not a hypocrite, I thought the eagles had the best qb in the NFC when Mcnabb was here, and now think that the Skins have the best QB with Mcnabb

2nd - Giants - Eli (only bc he has had the most success of any of the NFC qbs)

3rd - Cowboys - Romo (yes Romo is a choke artist)

4th - Kolb/Vick

Agreed.And pretty easy to assess. Its been that way for about 5 years now.

We know McNabb is McNabb

We know Eli is Eli and

We know Romo is Romo.

I will hedge my bet that within 2 years Kolb will be 1 or 2.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mcnabb

Romo

Manning

Kolb

Oh- and if this isnt enough

Barber/Jones

Portis/Johnson/Parker

Jacobs/Bradshaw

McCoy/Bell

This will be a fun year

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1st - Wash with Mcnabb (I am not a hypocrite, I thought the eagles had the best qb in the NFC when Mcnabb was here, and now think that the Skins have the best QB with Mcnabb

2nd - Giants - Eli (only bc he has had the most success of any of the NFC qbs)

3rd - Cowboys - Romo (yes Romo is a choke artist)

4th - Kolb/Vick

Swap 2nd and 3rs, and yeah I think you're right. Until Kolb proves it he can't be considered anything other than the lowest of this bunch.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Barber/Jones

Portis/Johnson/Parker

Jacobs/Bradshaw

McCoy/Bell

This will be a fun year

You are trippin guy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
IMO as of today

Dallas: ROMO

WASH: McNabb

NYG: Eli

PHI: Kolb

Now of course how does this look in 3 years is the real question.

beat me to it but yeah my thoughts exactly

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
QB will not matter its about the weapons around you.... so on that note.

Romo

Kolb

Mcnabb

Manning

The Giants have the worst collection of offensive talent in the East???

:unsure:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The Giants have the worst collection of offensive talent in the East???

:unsure:

Giants have some great talent at WR. Very underrated.

Nicks looks like he could be special.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
QB will not matter its about the weapons around you.... so on that note.

Romo

Kolb

Mcnabb

Manning

I disagree, qb's can raise wr play.

Do you really think that the likes of Smalls, Johnson, Pinkston, Lewis etc were winning those games for the eagles?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You can say what you want to but McNabb is still the best QB in this division.

What has Romo done for Dallas? Nothing!!!!!

Eli Manning has REGRESSED since the absence of Plaxico Burress.

And there is no way in HELL KEVIN KOLB is better than any of them!! :censored:

I AM AN EAGLES FAN TO THE CORE!!!

But D-MAC still rules this division at that position.

Philly, Dallas and the Giants will all find out in 2010!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The Giants have the worst collection of offensive talent in the East???

:unsure:

I disagree.

The Giants offense was good last year, it was their secondary that killed them.

Thats why they signed Rolle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You can say what you want to but McNabb is still the best QB in this division.

What has Romo done for Dallas? Nothing!!!!!

Eli Manning has REGRESSED since the absence of Plaxico Burress.

And there is no way in HELL KEVIN KOLB is better than any of them!! :censored:

I AM AN EAGLES FAN TO THE CORE!!!

But D-MAC still rules this division at that position.

Philly, Dallas and the Giants will all find out in 2010!!!!

McNabb hasnt been better than Eli or Romo for a few years now....try again

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The Giants have the worst collection of offensive talent in the East???

:unsure:

Sadly That running game is gonna ruin that team. They have one great WR and the rest average or below.

Plus personal opinion that OL is goin downhill.

I disagree, qb's can raise wr play.

Do you really think that the likes of Smalls, Johnson, Pinkston, Lewis etc were winning those games for the eagles?

I agree completely but that was Mcnabb at his prime When people would blitz just to contain Mcnabb. Yes QB make WRs better look at R. White and M. Ryan on the Falcons.... Favre and Rice????

I am just saying that might not be the case completely for the NFC East the past few years. Teams found talented WR on their roster that have already been their. For example Steve Smith and Mils Austin. the QBs never made them great at first they pushed themselves.

I am just hoping Kolb can take full advantage of all the proven talent we have on this roster. I cant wait to watch and see.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
McNabb hasnt been better than Eli or Romo for a few years now....try again

I DISAGREE!!!!

Yeah, Eli Manning won a Super Bowl (only because of that DEFENSE!!), but he was not better than McNabb before and will not be after!!!

Romo, PLEASE!!!!! Like I said, WHAT HAS ROMO WON? NOTHING!!!!

All I know is that I am TAKING ON ALL BETTORS THIS YEAR THAT MCNABB WINS AT LEAST ONE GAME AGAINST EVERYONE IN THE DIVISION!!!!!

NOW, TAKE THAT!!!!! :thumbsup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
QB will not matter its about the weapons around you.... so on that note.

Romo

Kolb

Mcnabb

Manning

:roll:

Only in TATE

How do you explain Brady and the 01 patriots?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You are trippin guy.

How? We have a good second year back, but he's nowhere near pro-bowl level. We have a good LG, question marks at C, RG and Rt, and we have a talented but undisciplined LT.

The Redskins have 3 pro-bowl backs, a top 5 draft choice to use on thier OL, and they dont have a bad O-line. Not to mention they dont have a clown coaching thier team anymore.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites