rstarter

Ongoing Derek Carr Thread

Recommended Posts

5 + 5 + 2=12

3 is 50% greater than 2.

You're as much a failure at math as qb talent evaluation.

So far, the only people who have ever graded carr over foles, is one lone shut-in with a schoolgirl crush on the man. And there's an entire 143(and counting) message board thread(in philly of all places, considering neither one plays there) making fun of both that schoolgirl and her crush as a result.

Which is the actual humor of this thread, apart from pulling your puppet strings to make you dance.

Oh, and are you ever going to answer?

Is carr going to be still holding foles nutz, as to who owned oaklands stadium(you know, carr's "house") with the better game played there, when oakland releases him?

 

This silliness right here. If we're going to go that route, then Carr threw more TDs in his rookie season than Foles did in two seasons and some. At some point in your incredibly faulty reasoning, you'll have to come to grips with Foles throwing up INTs at an almost 1:1 ratio to TDs thrown. Outside of 2013, he's been awfully consistent in that regard.

I have no problem with a QB tossing 20 INTs if he did so while also tossing for 40+ TDs. QBs are going to throw INTs so long as they throw the ball, but it's what you do between the turnovers that separates the elite from the pedestrian. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This silliness right here. If we're going to go that route, then Carr threw more TDs in his rookie season than Foles did in two seasons and some. At some point in your incredibly faulty reasoning, you'll have to come to grips with Foles throwing up INTs at an almost 1:1 ratio to TDs thrown. Outside of 2013, he's been awfully consistent in that regard.

I have no problem with a QB tossing 20 INTs if he did so while also tossing for 40+ TDs. QBs are going to throw INTs so long as they throw the ball, but it's what you do between the turnovers that separates the elite from the pedestrian.

We've moved past what the numbers mean, we're talking about your inability to do either basic addition or percents, and pretending you could.

And foles owning the keys to derecks house.

Forever...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

, guy's making throws that you'll not see Foles even try to attempt.

You're making this too hard on yourself. It's simple. Show a Derek Carr completing a corner route. It's a normal throw that all qbs should make. And yet..... Derek Carr hasn't made it. Why? Because maybe his "arm talent" isn't all that?

You keep saying foles "can't make all the throws". And yet...... Apparently neither can Carr.

So now we're in the midst of carr's fluke season (so far) where Carr hasn't gotten better as a qb (just doing the same things he did last year) and he doesn't even have the arm talent to complete a simple corner route? Shouldn't the raiders trade this dude in the offseason for a qb who can make "all the throws" by your logic?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wont lie, this season foles may not make all dem throws because he has friggin austin as his go to guy. Not amari cooper and crabtree. The same Jones Carr failed with, Rodgers is making him look like a star again.

All dem throws doe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

FolesMaclinOut.gif

 

Look at the cushion on that throw. Saying that he threw the ball with velocity, into a tight window, is really a joke.

 

CarrBShoulder.gif

 

This fits the bill, as far as throwing with velocity into a tight window is concerned.

Love how the Derek Carr gif is sped up and the Foles gif is slowed down and you want to comment on Velocity!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why do we even compary Carr with Foles any longer? rstarter himself set Aaron Rodgers as the benchmark for Carr. We should compare gifs of him and Carr. Not lowly Nick "career backup" Foles..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why do we even compary Carr with Foles any longer? rstarter himself set Aaron Rodgers as the benchmark for Carr. We should compare gifs of him and Carr. Not lowly Nick "career backup" Foles..

 

How is the simple mind going to engage in a comparison between Carr and Rodgers, when it's' still stuck on Foles being the more talented QB?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hope he dominates. Got both him and Cooper in one draftkings lineup and Crabtree in another. So far so good, first quarter td to Crabtree.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He's got to stick with the plays. This offense uses the short game to open up the deep ball. Also hope they start using Murray more because Carr hasn't enjoyed too much success throwing it thus far (to put it mildly.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Complete a short pass. Crabtree goes for 20.

Their o-line is really good. Carr gets no pressure.

Missing a lot of guys wide open. Missing another out route to Crabtree wide open. Pass was way high for some reason. He was stupid open.

Almost picked off another short 5 yd curl on 3rd down.

Missed cooper wide open for a first down on 3rd down. It's just a slant. Behind and way late.

His td pass was a great catch on another high throw. He needs to calm down. (He also needs to get his footwork together but that's just not gonna change it seems).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Complete a short pass. Crabtree goes for 20.

Their o-line is really good. Carr gets no pressure.

Missing a lot of guys wide open. Missing another out route to Crabtree wide open. Pass was way high for some reason. He was stupid open.

Almost picked off another short 5 yd curl on 3rd down.

Missed cooper wide open for a first down on 3rd down. It's just a slant. Behind and way late.

His td pass was a great catch on another high throw. He needs to calm down. (He also needs to get his footwork together but that's just not gonna change it seems).

 

:roll:

 

So now he's succeeding because his team is stacked? Yeah, that great franchise the Oakland Raiders, they just make every QB look great right? Michael Crabtree is pretty much Jerry Rice. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Raiders built up a solid team.. Solid D all around, solid wrs and rb, solid oline, carr only has to make smart throws.

 

No s***. Tom Brady has made a career out of "making smart throws." That's kind of the entire point of the QB position. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

:roll:

So now he's succeeding because his team is stacked? Yeah, that great franchise the Oakland Raiders, they just make every QB look great right? Michael Crabtree is pretty much Jerry Rice.

You're dumb if you can't see the talent Oakland has on offense now. Cooper is legit, Murray is good, strong offensive line. Crabtree is a solid receiver who struggled with a terrible qb in SF. Hell even Boldin and Davis couldn't do anything with Kaep.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You're dumb if you can't see the talent Oakland has on offense now. Cooper is legit, Murray is good, strong offensive line. Crabtree is a solid receiver who struggled with a terrible qb in SF. Hell even Boldin and Davis couldn't do anything with Kaep.

 

Ok, and the team was 3-13 last year and got blown out on the regular. It's laughable to try to diminish what Carr is doing this year by saying moronic statements like "hur hur all Carr is doing is making the reads and throwing the ball, the receiver is the one catching it!" 

 

You people are getting so desperate for excuses that you've resorted to acting like the Raiders are the gold standard hiding Carr's suckage because they finally added a playmaker in the draft this year. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now